Volume 11 · Number 3 · Pages 539–549
Consciousness as Self-Description in Differences

Diana Gasparyan

Log in to download the full text for free

> Citation > Similar > References > Add Comment


Context: Contemporary philosophy of consciousness has not yet come up with an acceptable theory of consciousness. Philosophers are still not able to reach agreement, and have come to a deadlock, since all possible approaches seem to have been exhausted and all the arguments repeatedly discussed. Problem: It may be assumed that the crisis has been caused by factors rooted in initial, wrong attitudes to knowledge or, more specifically, in epistemology focused on first-order cybernetics. The situation might be altered if philosophy of consciousness can be refocused on second-order cybernetics. This means that any attempt to apply the subject-object model to consciousness and specifically to reflection should be given up, while consciousness should not be seen as a certain objective essence observable by a researcher. It also means that the principles underlying theories of consciousness should be revised: any attempts that aim to explain the mechanism of generating consciousness through non-consciousness should be abandoned. The purpose of this article is methodological, pointing out the approaches to studying consciousness that might be more effective. It also gives the author’s vision of a new way of treating consciousness, taking into account the stated methodology. Method: Theoretical conceptual methods of argumentation, such as logical (deduction) and philosophical (phenomenology) kinds of proof. Results: The research shows that the epistemology underlying second-order cybernetics can eliminate many of the paradoxes typical of present-day theories of consciousness that are related to different versions of reductionism. It also explains that, in contrast to the dualistic subject-object model used for description of consciousness, the latter can and should be seen as a strictly self-describing system, where the diversity of forms and states is explained by inherent differences. Implications: The article could be productive for epistemic theories, philosophy of mind theories, mind-body theories, and phenomenological theories of consciousness. Constructivist content: The research applies the principles of von Foerster’s second-order cybernetics, von Glasersfeld’s radical constructivism, and some of Bateson’s ideas about difference, information, and mind structure directly to the epistemological assumptions underlying philosophy of consciousness.

Key words: Philosophy of consciousness, consciousness, performativity, first-order cybernetics, second-order cybernetics, reflection, self-reflection, self-description, differences.


Gasparyan D. (2016) Consciousness as self-description in differences. Constructivist Foundations 11(3): 539–549. http://constructivist.info/11/3/539

Export article citation data: Plain Text · BibTex · EndNote · Reference Manager (RIS)

Similar articles

Scott B. (2016) Cybernetic Foundations for Psychology
Sweeting B. & Hohl M. (2015) Exploring Alternatives to the Traditional Conference Format: Introduction to the Special Issue on Composing Conferences
Hawes R. (2013) Art & Neurophenomenology: Putting the Experience Before the Words
Weiss M. G. (2013) Non-dualistic Sex. Josef Mitterer’s Non-dualistic Philosophy in the Light of Judith Butler’s (De)Constructivist Feminism
Scott B. & Bansal A. (2013) A Cybernetic Computational Model for Learning and Skill Acquisition


Armstrong D. M. (1993) A materialist theory of the mind. Revised edition. Routledge, London. Originally published in 1968. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Ashby W. R. (1956) An introduction to cybernetics. Chapman and Hall, London. https://archive.org/details/introductiontocy00ashb
Ataria Y., Dor-Ziderman Y. & Berkovich-Ohana A. (2015) How does it feel to lack a sense of boundaries? The case of mindfulness meditation. Consciousness and Cognition 37: 133–147. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Austin J. L (1962) How to do things with words. Harvard University Press, Cambridge. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Bateson G. (1972) Form, substance, and difference. In: Bateson G., Steps to an ecology of mind. University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL: 448–466. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Bateson G. (1979) Mind and nature: A necessary unity. Hampton Press, Cresskill NJ. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Bennett M., Dennett D., Hacker P. & Searle J. (2007) Neuroscience and philosophy: Brain, mind, and language. Columbia University Press, New York. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Bickle J. (2012) A brief history of neuroscience’s actual influences on mind-brain reductionalism. In: Gozzano S. & Hill C. (eds.) New perspectives on type identity. Cambridge University Press, New York: 43–65. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Bishop J. M. & Nasuto J. S. (2005) Second-order cybernetics and enactive perception. Kybernetes 34(9/10): 1309–1320 http://cepa.info/835
Bitbol M. & Antonova E. (2016) On the too often overlooked radicality of neurophenomenology. Constructivist Foundations 11(2): 354–356 http://constructivist.info/11/2/354
Bitbol M. & Petitmengin C. (2013) On the possibility and reality of introspection. Kairos 6: 173–198 http://cepa.info/2298
Blakemore S. J., Wolpert D. M. & Frith C. D. (2002) Abnormalities in the awareness of action. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 6: 237–242. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Block N. (1990) Consciousness and accessibility. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 13(4): 596–598. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Carruthers P. (2011) Higher-order theories of consciousness. In: Zalta E. N. (eds.) The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Fall 2011 Edition. http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2011/entries/consciousness-higher
Chalmers D. (1995) Facing up to the problem of consciousness. Journal of Consciousness Studies 2(3): 200–219. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Chalmers D. (1996) The conscious mind: In search of a fundamental theory. Oxford University Press, New York. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Chalmers D. (1997) Facing up to the problem of consciousness. In: Shear J. (ed.) Explaining consciousness: The “hard problem.” MIT Press, Cambridge MA: 9–30. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Chalmers D. (2003) Consciousness and its place in nature. In: Stich S. & Warfield F. (eds.) The Blackwell guide to philosophy of mind. Blackwell, Malden MA: 102–142. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Churchland P. S. (2013) Touching a nerve: The self as brain. W. W. Norton, New York. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Coecke B. (2008) Introducing categories to the practicing physicist. in: Sica G. (ed.) What is category theory? Polimetrica, Monza: 45–74. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Crane L. (2007) What is the mathematical structure of quantum spacetime? arXiv:0706.4452. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Crick F. (1994) The astonishing hypothesis: The scientific search for the soul. Charles Scribner’s Sons, New York. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Demircioglu E. (2013) Physicalism and phenomenal concepts. Philosophical Studies 165(1): 257–277. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Dennett D. (1992) Consciousness explained. Back Bay Books, New York. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Descartes R. (1966) Meditations on first philosophy. Translated by John Cottingham. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Di Paolo E. (2009) Overcoming autopoiesis. In: Magalhães R. & Sanchez R. (eds.) Autopoiesis in organization: Theory and practice. Emerald, Bingley: 43–68 http://cepa.info/2366
Dilthey W. (1977) Descriptive psychology and historical understanding. Translated by R. M. Zaner and K. L. Heiges with an introduction by R. A. Makkreel. Martinus Nijhof, The Hague. German original published in 1894. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Foerster H. von (1979) Cybernetics of Cybernetics. In: Krippendorff K. (ed.) Communication and Control in Society. Gordon and Breach, New York: 5–8 http://cepa.info/1707
Foerster H. von (1981) Notes on an epistemology for living things. In: Foerster H. von, Observing systems. Intersystems, Seaside CA: 258–265. Originally published in 1972 http://cepa.info/1655
Foerster H. von (1992) Ethics and second-order cybernetics. Cybernetics & Human Knowing 1(1): 9–25 http://cepa.info/1742
Foerster H. von (2003) On constructing a reality. In: Foerster H. von, Understanding understanding: Essays on cybernetics and cognition. Springer, New York: 211–227. Originally published in 1973 http://cepa.info/1278
Foerster H. von (ed.) (1995) Cybernetics of cybernetics. Future Systems, Minneapolis MN. Originally published in 1974. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Freud S. (2002) Civilization and its discontents. Penguin, London. German original published as: Freud S. (1930) Das Unbehagen in der Kultur. Internationaler Psychoanalytischer Verlag, Vienna. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Funkhouser E., (2007) Multiple realizability. Philosophy Compass 2(2): 303–315. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Gasparyan D. (2015) What can the global observer know? Constructivist Foundations 10(2): 227–237 http://constructivist.info/10/2/227
Gennaro R. (1995) Consciousness and self-consciousness: A defense of the higher-order thought theory of consciousness. John Benjamins, Amsterdam. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Gennaro R. (2012) The consciousness paradox. MIT Press, Cambridge MA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Gennaro R. (ed.) (2004) Higher-order theories of consciousness. John Benjamins, Amsterdam. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Gergen K. J. (1997) Realities and relationships: Soundings in social construction. Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Gibson J. J. (1977) The theory of affordances. In: Shaw R. E. & Bransford J. (eds.) Perceiving, acting, and knowing. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale NJ. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Glanville R. (2002) Second order cybernetics. In: Encyclopaedia of life support systems. EoLSS Publishers, Oxford. (Web publication http://cepa.info/2708
Glasersfeld E. von (1987) The construction of knowledge. InterSystems Publications, Salinas CA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Glasersfeld E. von (1995) Radical constructivism: A way of knowing and learning. Falmer Press, London. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Güzeldere G. (1995) Problems of consciousness: A perspective on contemporary issues, current debates. Journal of Consciousness Studies 2(2): 112–143. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Harman G. (1990) The intrinsic quality of experience. Philosophical Perspectives (4): 31–52. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Harnad S. (1990) The symbol grounding problem. Physica D42: 335–346. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Harnad S. (1993) Grounding symbols in the analog world with neural nets. Think 2: 12–78. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Harre R. (1989) Metaphysics and methodology: Some prescriptions for social psychological research. European Journal of Social Psychology 19(5): 439–453. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Hellman G. & Thompson F. (1975) Physicalism: Ontology, determination and reduction. Journal of Philosophy 72: 551–564. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Hillman J. (1995) A psyche the size of the Earth. A psychological foreward. In: Roszak T., Gomes M. & Kanner A. (eds.) (1995) Ecopsychology. Sierra Books, San Francisco CA: Xvii-xxiii. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Hoffmeyer J. (2008) An examination into the signs of life and the life of signs. University of Scranton Press, Scranton PA. Originally published in 2005. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Houser N. & Kloesel C. (1992) The essential Peirce. Indiana University Press, Bloomington IN. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Hume D. (2010) A treatise on human nature. Edited by David Fate Norton & Mary J. Norton. Oxford University Press, Oxford. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Humphreys N. (1992) A history of the mind. Chatto and Windus, London. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Husserl E. (1931) Ideas: General introduction to pure phenomenology. Translated by W. Boyce Gibson. MacMillan, New York. German original published in 1913. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Husserl E. (1960) Cartesian meditations: An introduction to phenomenology. Translated by Dorian Cairns. Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Husserl E. (1982) Ideas pertaining to a pure phenomenology and to a phenomenological philosophy: First book, general introduction to a pure phenomenology. Kluwer, Boston MA. German original published in 1913. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Jackson F. (1982) Epiphenomenal qualia. Philosophical Quarterly 32: 127–136. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Jackson F. (1986) What Mary didn’t know. The Journal of Philosophy 83(5): 291–295. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
James W. (1890) The principles of psychology. Henry Holt, New York. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Kirchhoff M. D. & Hutto D. D. (2016) Never mind the gap. Constructivist Foundations 11(2): 346–353 http://constructivist.info/11/2/346
Kordeš U. (2016) Going beyond theory. Constructivist Foundations 11(2): 375–385 http://constructivist.info/11/2/375
Kriegel U. (2009) Subjective consciousness. Oxford University Press, Oxford. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Lähteenmäki V. (2007) Orders of consciousness and forms of reflexivity in Descartes. In: Heinämaa S., Lähteenmäki V. & Remes P. (eds.) Consciousness: From perception to reflection in the history of philosophy. Springer, Dordrecht: 177–201. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Levine J. (1983) Materialism and qualia: The explanatory gap. Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 64: 354–361. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Levine J. (2001) Purple haze: The puzzle of consciousness. Oxford University Press, Oxford. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Locke J. (1975) An essay concerning human understanding. Clarendon Press, Oxford. Originally published in 1690. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Luhmann N. (1990) Essays on self-reference. Columbia University Press, New York. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Luhmann N. (1995) The paradoxy of observing systems. Cultural Critique 31: 37–55 http://cepa.info/2707
Luhmann N. (1997) Die Gesellschaft der Gesellschaft. Suhrkamp, Frankfurt. English translation: Luhmann N. (2012/2013) Theory of society. Stanford University Press, Stanford. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Luhmann N. (2000) The reality of the mass media. Translated by Kathleen Cross. Stanford University Press, Stanford. German original published in 1996. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Maturana H. R. & Varela F. J. (1980) Autopoiesis: The organization of the living. In: Maturana H. R. & Varela F. J. (eds.) Autopoiesis and cognition. Reidel, Dordrecht: 73–134. Originally published in 1974 http://cepa.info/552
Maturana H. R. (1980) Biology of cognition. In: Maturana H. R. & Varela F. J. (eds.) Autopoiesis and cognition. Reidel, Dordrecht: 5–58. Originally published in 1970 http://cepa.info/535
McCullagh M. (2000) Functionalism and self-consciousness. Mind and Language,15(5): 481–499. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
McGinn C. (1989) Can we solve the mind–body problem? Mind 98: 349–366. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
McGinn C. (1991) The problem of consciousness. Blackwell, Oxford. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Mead M. (1968) Cybernetics of cybernetics. In: Foerster H. P. H., White J. & Russell J. (eds.) Purposive systems. Spartan Books, New York: 1–11 http://cepa.info/2634
Merleau-Ponty M. (1962) Phenomenology of perception. Translated by Colin Smith. Routledge and Kegan Paul, London. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Merleau-Ponty M. (1968) The visible and the invisible‎. Edited by C. Lefort and translated by A. Lingis. Northwestern University Press, Evanston. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Metzinger T. (2003) Being no one: The self-model theory of subjectivity. MIT Press, Cmbridge MA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Miller J.-A. (1966) La suture. Cahiers pour l’Analyse 1: 37–49. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Nagel T. (1974) What is it like to be a bat? Philosophical Review 83: 435–456 http://cepa.info/2399
Nagel T. (1986) The view from nowhere. Oxford University Press, New York. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Nagel T. (2012) Mind and cosmos: Why the materialist neo-Darwinian conception of nature is almost certainly false. Oxford University Press, Oxford. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Natorp P. (1912) Allgemeine Psychologie nach kritischer Methode. J. C. B. Mohr, Tübingen. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Nelkin N. (1989) Unconscious sensations. Philosophical Psychology 2: 129–141. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Noë A. (2004) Action in perception. MIT Press, New York. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
O’Regan J. K. (2010) Explaining what people say about sensory qualia. In: Gangopadhyay N., Madary M. & Spicer F. (eds.) Perception, action and consciousness: Sensorimotor dynamics and two visual systems. Oxford University Press, Oxford: 31–50. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
O’Regan J. K., Myin E. & Noë A. (2005) Skill, corporality and alerting capacity in an account of sensory consciousness. Progress in Brain Research 150: 55–68. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Papineau D. (2002) Thinking about consciousness. Oxford University Press, Oxford. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Pavlov-Pinus K. (2015) Human knowledge and “as-if” knowledge of ideal observers. Constructivist Foundations 10(2): 239–240 http://constructivist.info/10/2/239
Penrose R. (1989) The emperor’s new mind: Computers, minds and the laws of physics. Oxford University Press, Oxford. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Penrose R. (1994) Shadows of the mind. Oxford University Press, Oxford. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Piaget J. (1954) The construction of reality in the child. Basic Books, New York. French original published in 1950. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Piccinini G. (2004) Functionalism, computationalism, and mental states. Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science 35: 811–833. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Pierce B. (2012) Is the function of consciousness to act as an interface? In: Paglieri F. (ed.) Consciousness in interaction. John Benjamins, Amsterdam: 73–88. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Pinker S. (2007) The stuff of thought: Language as a window into human nature. Penguin Books, London. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Place U. T. (1956) Is consciousness a brain process? British Journal of Psychology 47(1): 44–50. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Rickert H. (1962) Science and history: A critique of positivist epistemology. Van Nostrand, Princeton. German original published as: Rickert H. (1926) Kulturwissenschaft und Naturwissenschaft. 6th and 7th expanded editions, Mohr Siebeck, Tübingen. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Ricoeur P. (1965) De l’interpretation. Ed. du Seuil, Paris. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Rockmore T. (2005) On constructivist epistemology. Rowman & Littlefield, Oxford. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Saussure F. de (1983) Course in general linguistics. Translated by Roy Harris. Duckworth, London. French original published in 1916. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Schrödinger E. (1944) What is life? Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Schrödinger E. (1958) Mind and matter. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Scott B. (1996) Second-order cybernetics as cognitive methodology. Systems Research 13(3): 393–406 http://cepa.info/1810
Searle J. (1979) Expression and meaning: Studies in the theory of speech acts. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Searle J. (1980) Minds, brains and programs. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 3(3): 417–424. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Shagrir O. (2005) The rise and fall of computational functionalism. In: Ben-Menahem Y. (ed.) Hilary Putnam. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge: 220–250. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Smolin L. (1997) The life of the cosmos. Oxford University Press, Oxford. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Spencer Brown G. (1969) Laws of form. Allen & Unwin, London http://cepa.info/2382
Strawson G. (2016) Consciousness isn’t a mystery. It’s matter. New York Times 16 May 2016. http://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/16/opinion/consciousness-isnt-a-mystery-its-matter.html
Thompson E. (2007) Mind in nature: Biology, phenomenology, and the science of mind. The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Thompson E., Lutz A. & Cosmelli D. (2005) Neurophenomenology: An introduction for neurophilosophers. In: Brook A., Akins K. & Brook A. K. (eds.) Cognition and the brain: The philosophy and neuroscience movement. Cambridge University Press, New York: 40–97 http://cepa.info/2374
Tononi G. (2012) Phi: A voyage from the brain to the soul. Pantheon Books, New York. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Tschacher W. & Scheier C. (2001) Embodied cognitive science: Concepts, methods and implications for psychology. In: Matthies M., Malchow H. & Kriz J. (eds.) Integrative systems approaches to natural and social dynamics. Springer, Berlin: 551–567. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Tye M. & Wright B. (2011) Is there a phenomenology of thought? In: Bayne T. & Montague M. (eds.) Cognitive phenomenology. Oxford University Press, Oxford: 326–344. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Van Gulick R. (1985) Physicalism and the subjectivity of the mental. Philosophical Topics 13: 51–70. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Van Gulick R. (2000) Inward and upward: Reflection, introspection and self-awareness. Philosophical Topics 28: 275–305. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Van Gulick R. (2014) Consciousness. In: Zalta E. N. (ed.) The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (Spring 2014 Edition). http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2014/entries/consciousness
Varela F. J. (1979) Principles of biological autonomy. Elsevier, Amsterdam. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Varela F. J. (1994) A cognitive view of the immune system. World Futures 42(1): 31–40. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Varela F. J. (1996) Neurophenomenology: A methodological remedy for the hard problem. Journal of Consciousness Studies 3(4): 330–349 http://cepa.info/1893
Varela F. J., Thompson E. & Rosch E. (1991) The embodied mind: Cognitive science and human experience. MIT Press, Cambridge MA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Velmans M. (1990) Consciousness, brain and the physical world. Philosophical Psychology 3(1): 77–99. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Vermersch P. (2009) Describing the practice of introspection. Journal of Consciousness Studies 16 (10–12): 20–57 http://cepa.info/2416
Vermersch P. (2016) Notes on the coupling between the observer and the observed in psycho-phenomenology. Constructivist Foundations 11(2): 391–393 http://constructivist.info/11/2/391
Weber A. & Varela F. J. (2002) Life after Kant: Natural purposes and the autopoietic foundations of biological individuality. Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 1: 97–125 http://cepa.info/2087
Whitehead A. N. (1929) Process and reality. An essay in cosmology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Windelband W. (1915) Geschichte und Naturwissenschaft. In: Windelband W., Präludien. Aufsätze und Reden zur Philosophie und ihrer Geschichte. Volume 2. Fifth expanded edition. J. C. M. Mohr (Paul Siebeck), Tübingen: 136–160. Originally published in 1894. http://digi.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/diglit/windelband1915ga
Wittgenstein L. (1965) A lecture on ethics. The Philosophical Review 74: 3–12. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Wrathall M. & Kelly S. (1996) Existential phenomenology and cognitive science. The Electronic Journal of Analytic Philosophy 4. http://ejap.louisiana.edu/EJAP/1996.spring/wrathall.kelly.1996.spring.html

Comments: 0

To stay informed about comments to this publication and post comments yourself, please log in first.