Volume 12 · Number 3 · Pages 292–299
Coordination Produces Cognitive Niches, not just Experiences: A Semi-Formal Constructivist Ontology Based on von Foerster

Konrad Werner

Log in to download the full text for free

> Citation > Similar > References > Add Comment


Context: Von Foerster’s concept of eigenbehavior can be recognized against the broader context of enactivism as it has been advocated by Varela, Thompson and Rosch, by Noë and recently by Hutto and Myin, among others. This flourishing constellation of ideas is on its way to becoming the new paradigm of cognitive science. However, in my reading, enactivism, putting stress on the constitutive role of action when it comes to mind and perception, faces a serious philosophical challenge when attempting to account for the way we actually perceive our environments, most importantly for the fact that we perceive things or objects. Von Foester’s eigenbehavior is understood here as a concept supposed to take on this challenge. Problem: In this article I tackle the following issues: (1) Enactivism must be able to account for the apparent stability of the perceived world: this is not a realm of a never-ending flux of stimuli; it is a realm of stable things. (2) Enactivism is committed to the anti-Cartesian endeavor seeking to bridge the gap between the inner and the outer; between the subjective and the objective. Now, these two points constrain each other so that one cannot address (1) simply by regarding the apparent stability of things as a projection that springs out of the internal machinery binding inputs with outputs. This is because the very idea of such an internal machinery opposes (2), i.e., it employs the Cartesian dichotomy. So, enactivism is in need of an account of (1) that would not oppose its anti-Cartesian commitment. Method: I introduce the ontology of location and niche theory, as it has been brought forth by Varzi, Casati, and Smith, and develop it so that it can be used in the philosophy of mind. This is a conceptual, semi-formal philosophical analysis. Results: I shall come up with the idea of object conceived of a product of action, and - drawing on von Foerster’s central idea - as a product of coordination of perceptions. Yet, it is not coordination of stimuli but coordination of cognitive connections. The notion of connection is thus articulated in the article and cast as the central concept in my proposal. Implications: We are able to account for both (1) and (2. The apparent stability of the perceived world is due to the setting up and maintaining of connections between the perceiver and the things perceived, resulting in the establishment of what I call a cognitive niche. Constructivist content: Constructivism, broadly construed, takes, in my reading, a negative stance in the first place. Namely, it opposes what I call the metaphysics of the ready-made world. So, it holds that there is no ready-made reality; however it remains open when it comes to positive claims: a mind-independent reality does not exist at all or it does exist but it is not ready-made and as such it must be brought to completion, so to speak, or enacted, as Varela et al. would say, by a cognitive subject. In this article, I follow the latter and address one specific issue: how the enacted world gains its relatively stable architecture.

Key words: Enactivism, location, eigenbehavior, niche, cognition, perception, connection.


Werner K. (2017) Coordination produces cognitive niches, not just experiences: A semi-formal constructivist ontology based on von Foerster. Constructivist Foundations 12(3): 292–299. http://constructivist.info/12/3/292

Export article citation data: Plain Text · BibTex · EndNote · Reference Manager (RIS)

Similar articles

Gallagher S. (2018) Decentering the Brain: Embodied Cognition and the Critique of Neurocentrism and Narrow-Minded Philosophy of Mind
Fultot M. F., Nie L. & Carello C. (2016) Perception-Action Mutuality Obviates Mental Construction
Matyja J. R. & Schiavio A. (2013) Enactive Music Cognition: Background and Research Themes
Hawes R. (2013) Art & Neurophenomenology: Putting the Experience Before the Words
Maturana H. R. (2012) Reflections on My Collaboration with Francisco Varela


Betti A. (2016) Kazimierz Twardowski. In: Zalta E. N. (ed.) The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (Summer 2016 Edition). ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Buchanan B. (2008) Onto-ethologies: The animal environments of Uexküll, Heidegger, Merleau-Ponty, and Deleuze. Suny Press, New York. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Casati R. & Varzi A. (1999) Parts and places: The structures of spatial representation. MIT Press, Cambridge MA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Cocchiarella N. (1996) Conceptual realism as a formal ontology. In: Poli R. & Simons P. (eds.) Formal ontology. Kluwer, Dordrecht: 27–60. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Cummins F. & De Jesus P. (2016) The loneliness of the enactive cell: Towards a bio-enactive framework. Adaptive Behavior 24(3): 149–159. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Cummins F. (2014) Voice, (inter-) subjectivity, and real time recurrent interaction. Frontiers in Psychology 5: 760. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
De Jaegher H. & Di Paolo E. (2007) Participatory sense-making. Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 6(4): 485–507 http://cepa.info/2387
De Jesus P. (2016) From enactive phenomenology to biosemiotic enactivism. Adaptive Behavior 24(2): 130–146 http://cepa.info/2632
De Jesus P. (2016) Making sense of (autopoietic) enactive embodiment: A gentle appraisal. Phainomena 25(98–99): 33–56 http://cepa.info/4133
Di Paolo E., Buhrmann T. & Barandiaran X. (2017) Sensorimotor life: An enactive proposal. Oxford University Press, New York. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Dupuy J.-P. (2009) On the origins of cognitive science: The mechanization of mind. MIT Press, Cambridge MA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Foerster H. von (2003) Objects: Tokens for (eigen-)behaviors. In: Foerster H. von, Understanding understanding: Essays on cybernetics and cognition. Springer, New York: 261–272. Originally published in 1976 http://cepa.info/1270
Foerster H. von (2003) On constructing a reality. In: Foerster H. von, Understanding understanding. Springer, New York: 211–227. Originally published in 1973 http://cepa.info/1278
Froese T. (2010) From cybernetics to second-order cybernetics: A comparative analysis of their central ideas. Constructivist Foundations 5(2): 75–85. http: //cepa.info/148 http://constructivist.info/5/2/075
Froese T. (2011) From second-order cybernetics to enactive cognitive science: Varela’s turn from epistemology to phenomenology. Systems Research and Behavioural Science 28(6): 631–645 http://cepa.info/449
Gasparyan D. (2015) What can the global observer know? Constructivist Foundations 10(2): 227–237 http://constructivist.info/10/2/227
Gibson J. J. (1973) On the concept of “formless invariants” in visual perception. Leonardo 6(1): 43–45. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Godfrey-Smith P. (1996) Complexity and the function of mind in nature. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Godfrey-Smith P. (2016) Other minds: The octopus, the sea, and the deep origins of consciousness. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, New York. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Grene M. (1974) The understanding of nature. Reidel, Dordrecht. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Harrington A. (1996) Reenchanted science: Holism in German culture from Wilhelm II to Hitler. Princeton University Press, Princeton. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2016/entries/twardowski ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Hutchinson G. E. (1957) Concluding remarks. Cold Spring Harbor Symposia on Quantitative Biology 22(2): 415–427. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Hutto D. D. & Myin E. (2013) Radicalizing enactivism: Basic minds without content. MIT Press, Cambridge MA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Hutto D. D. & Myin E. (2017) Evolving enactivism: Basic minds meet content. MIT Press, Cambridge MA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Hutto D. D. & Myin E. (forthcoming) Going radical. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Hutto D. D. (2015) REC: Revolution effected by clarification. Topoi, online first. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Ingarden R. (2013) Controversy over the existence of the world. Volume 1. Peter Lang, Frankfurt am Main/New York. Polish original published in in 1947. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Kohn E. (2013) How forests think: Toward an anthropology beyond the human. University of California Press, Berkeley CA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Latour B. (2013) An inquiry into modes of existence: An anthropology of the moderns Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Law J. (2009) Seeing like a survey. Cultural sociology 3(2): 239–256. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Law J. (2015) What’s wrong with a one-world world? Distinktion: Scandinavian Journal of Social Theory 16(1): 126–139. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Leśniewski S. (1992) Foundations of the general theory of sets I. In: Leśniweski S., Collected works. Kluwer, Dordrecht: 129–173. Originally published in 1916. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Lettvin J. Y. Maturana H. R., McCulloch W. S. & Pitts W. H. (1968) What the frog’s eye tells the frog’s brain. In: Corning W. C. & Balaban M. (eds.) The mind: Biological approaches to its functions. Wiley, New York: 233–258. Originally published in 1959. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Lewontin R. (1983) The organism as the subject and object of evolution. Scientia 118: 63–82. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Lewontin R. (2000) The triple helix. Gene, organism, and environment. Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Llored J.-P. & Harré R. (2014) Developing the mereology of chemistry. In: Calosi C. & Graziani P. (eds.) Mereology and the sciences. Springer, Dordrecht: 189–212. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Maturana H. R. (1978) Cognition. In: Hejl P. M., Köck W. K. & Roth G. (eds.) Wahrnehmung und Kommunikation. Peter Lang, Frankfurt: 29–49 http://cepa.info/550
Merleau-Ponty M. (2002) Phenomenology of perception. Routledge, London. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Mitterer J. (2001) Die Flucht aus der Beliebigkeit [The flight from contingency]. Fischer, Frankfurt am Main. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Mol A. (2002) The body multiple: Ontology in medical practice. Duke University Press, Durham NC. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Noë A. (2004) Action in perception. MIT Press, Cambridge MA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
O’Regan K. & Noë A. (2001) A sensorimotor account of vision and visual consciousness. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 24(5): 939–973. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Parzanowski J. (1996) The way of truth. In: Poli R. & Simons P. (eds.) Formal ontology. Kluwer, Dordrecht: 61–130. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Perzanowski J. (1993) Locative ontology Parts I–III. Logic and Logical Philosophy I: 7–94. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Perzanowski J. (2004) Toward combination metaphysics. Reports of Mathematical Logic 38: 93–116. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Perzanowski J. (2012) Towards combination metaphysics. In: Perzanowski J., Art of philosophy: A selection of Jerzy Perzanowski’s Works. Edited by J. Sytnik-Czetwertyński. Ontos Verlag, Frankfurt am Main: 45–68. Originally published in 2004. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Petitot J. & Smith B. (1996) Physics and the phenomenal world. In: Poli R. & Simons P. (eds.) Formal ontology. Kluwer, Dordrecht: 233–253. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Piaget J. (1975) L’equilibration des structures cognitives: Problème central du développement. Presses Universitaires de France, Paris. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Pickering A. (2017) The ontological turn: Taking different worlds seriously. Social Analysis. 62(2); 134–150. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Pinker S. (2010) The cognitive niche: Coevolution of intelligence, sociality, and language. PNAS 107(11): 8993–8999. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Plessner H. (1928) Die Stufen des Organischen und der Mensch. Einleitung in die philosophische Anthropologie. De Gruyter, Berlin. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Putnam H. (1975) The meaning of “meaning.” Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science 7: 131–193. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Simons P. M. (1987) Parts: A study in ontology. Clarendon Press, Oxford. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Smith B. & Varzi A. (1999) The niche. Noûs 33(2): 214–238. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Smith B. & Varzi A. (2000) Fiat and bona fide boundaries. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 60(2): 401–420. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Smith B. & Varzi A. (2001) Environmental metaphysics. In: Meixner U. (ed.) Metaphysics in the Post-Metaphysical Age. Proceedings of the 22th International Wittgenstein Symposium. Hölder-Pichler-Tempsky, Vienna: 231–239. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Smith B. (1996) Mereotopology: A theory of parts and boundaries. Data and Knowledge Engineering 20: 287–303. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Smith B. (1998) Basic concepts of formal ontology. In: Guarino N. (ed.) Formal ontology in information systems. IOS Press US: 19–28. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Smith B. (2004) Beyond concepts: Ontology as reality representation. In: Proceedings of the third international conference on formal ontology in information systems (FOIS 2004) IOS Press, Amsterdam: 73–84. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Sterelny K. (2010) Minds: Extended or scaffolded? Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 9: 465–481. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Thomasson A. (2016) Roman Ingarden. In: Zalta E. (ed.) The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (Fall 2016 edition) ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Twardowski K. (1912) O czynnościach i wytworach. Kilka uwag z pogranicza psychologii, gramatyki i logiki. In: Twardowski K., Księga Pamiątkowa ku uczczeniu 250-tej rocznicy założenia Uniwersytetu Lwowskiego przez króla Jana Kazimierza. Volume II. Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Lwowskiego, Lviv: 1–33. English translation: Twardowski K. (1999) On actions, products and other topics in philosophy. Edited by J. Brandl and J. Wolenski. Rodopi, Amsterdam: 103–132. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Tønnessen M. (2015) Uexküllian phenomenology. Chinese Semiotic Studies 11(3): 347–369 http://cepa.info/2685
Uexküll J. von (1909) Umwelt und Innenwelt der Tiere. Springer, Berlin http://cepa.info/2404
Uexküll J. von (1920) Theoretische Biologie. Paetel, Berlin. English translation: Uexküll J. (1926) Theoretical biology. Harcourt, Brace & Co., New York. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Uexküll J. von (1926) Theoretical biology. Harcourt, Brace & Co, New York. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Uexküll J. von (1934) Streifzüge durch die Umwelten von Tieren und Menschen. Springer, Berlin. English translation: Uexküll J. von (1957) A stroll through the worlds of animals and men. In: Schiller C. H. (ed.) Instinctive behavior: The development of a modern concept. International Universities Press, New York: 5–80 http://cepa.info/2403
van Duijn M., Keijzer K. & Franken D. (2006) Principles of minimal cognition: Casting cognition as sensorimotor coordination. Adaptive Behavior 14(2): 157–170. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Varela F. J. (1991) Organism: A meshwork of selfless selves. In: Tauber A. I. (ed.) Organism and the origins of Self. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht: 79–107 http://cepa.info/1959
Varela F. J. (1996) Neurophenomenology: A methodological remedy for the hard problem. Journal of Consciousness Studies 3: 330–335 http://cepa.info/1893
Varela F. J. (1997) Patterns of life: Intertwining identity and cognition. Brain and Cognition 34: 72–87 http://cepa.info/2010
Varela F. J., Thompson E. & Rosch E. (1991) The embodied mind: Cognitive science and human experience. MIT Press, Cambridge MA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Varzi A. (2016) Mereology. In: Zalta E. N. (ed.) The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (Winter 2016 Edition) ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Vörös S., Froese T. & Riegler A. (2016) Epistemological odyssey. Constructivist Foundations 11(2): 189–204 http://constructivist.info/11/2/189
Weber A. & Varela F. J. (2002) Life after Kant: Natural purposes and the autopoietic foundations of biological individuality. Phenomenology and the cognitive sciences 1: 97–125 http://cepa.info/2087
Werner K. (2015) Towards a PL-metaphysics of perception. Constructivist Foundations 11(1): 148–157 http://constructivist.info/11/1/148
Werner K. (2016) What is it like to be a metaphysical subject: An essay on early Wittgenstein, our epistemic position and beyond. Philosophia 44(3): 921–946. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Werner K. (2017) Metaphilosophy of mind: How do minds investigate minds? Refutation of the theocentric view. Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science 51(1): 120–140. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Wittgenstein L. (1922) Tractatus logico-philosophicus. Kegan Paul, London. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Woleński J. (1989) Logic and philosophy in the Lvov-Warsaw School. Kluwer, Dordrecht. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar

Comments: 0

To stay informed about comments to this publication and post comments yourself, please log in first.