Volume 8 · Number 3 ·
Pages 269–279
A Defense of Introspection from Within
Michel Bitbol & Claire Petitmengin
Log in to download the full text for free
Abstract
Context: We are presently witnessing a revival of introspective methods, which implicitly challenges an impressive list of in-principle objections that were addressed to introspection by various philosophers and by behaviorists. Problem: How can one overcome those objections and provide introspection with a secure basis? Results: A renewed definition of introspection as “enlargement of the field of attention and contact with re-enacted experience,” rather than “looking-within,” is formulated. This entails (i) an alternative status of introspective phenomena, which are no longer taken as revelations of some an sich slice of experience, but as full-fledged experiences; and (ii) an alternative view of the validity of first-person reports as “performative coherence” rather than correspondence. A preliminary empirical study of the self-assessed reliability of introspective data using the elicitation interview method is then carried out. It turns out that subjects make use of reproducible processual criteria in order to probe into the authenticity and completeness of their own introspective reports. Implications: Introspective inquiry is likely to have enough resources to “take care of itself.” Constructivist content: It is argued that the failure of the introspectionist wave of the turn of the 19th/20th centuries is mostly due to its unconditional acceptance of the representationalist theory of knowledge, and that alternative non-representationalist criteria of validity give new credibility to introspective knowledge.
Key words: Introspection, first-person, phenomenology, consciousness, awareness, epistemology, non-representationalism, experience, subjectivity
Citation
Bitbol M. & Petitmengin C. (2013) A defense of introspection from within. Constructivist Foundations 8(3): 269–279. http://constructivist.info/8/3/269
Export article citation data: Plain Text · BibTex · EndNote · Reference Manager (RIS)
Similar articles
References
Ayer A. J. (1946) Language, truth, and logic. Gollancz, London. Originally published in 1936. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Bar-On D. (2004) Speaking my mind. Oxford University Press, Oxford. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Barrett L. F., Mesquita B., Ochsner K. N. & Gross J. J. (2007) The experience of emotion. Annual Review of Psychology 58: 373–403. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Becker M. & Pashler H. (2002) Volatile visual representations: Failing to detect changes in recently processed information. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 9: 744–750. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Bitbol M. & Petitmengin C. (2013) On the possibility and reality of introspection. Kairos 6: 173–198. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Bitbol M. & Petitmengin C. (2013) The science of mind as it could have been: About the contingency of the (quasi-)disappearance of introspection in psychology. In: Soler L. & Trizio E. (eds.) Science as it could have been. Routledge, London. In press. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Boring E. G. (1953) A history of introspection. Psychological Bulletin 50: 169–189. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Buckner W., Reese E. & Reese R. (1997) Eye movement as an indicator of sensory components in thought. Journal of Counseling Psychology 34: 283–287. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Chalmers D. (2003) The content and epistemology of phenomenal belief. In: Smith Q. & Jokic A. (eds.) Consciousness: New philosophical perspectives. Oxford University Press, Oxford. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Costall (2006) “Introspectionism” and ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Danziger K. (1994) Constructing the subject, historical origins of psychological research. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Dennett D. (1992) Consciousness explained. Back Bay Books, Santa Ana CA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Dennett D. (2002) How could I be wrong? ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Depraz N., Varela F. J. & Vermersch P. (2003) On becoming aware. John Benjamins, Amsterdam. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Descartes R. (1990) Méditations métaphysiques. Livre de Poche, Paris. Originally published in 1641. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Ericsson K. A. & Simon H. A. (1984) Protocol analysis: verbal reports as data. MIT Press, Cambridge MA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Garfield J. L. (1989) The myth of Jones and the mirror of nature: Reflections on introspection. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 50: 1–26. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Horgan T. & Kriegel U. (2007) Phenomenal epistemology: What is consciousness that we may know it so well? Philosophical Issues 17: 123–144. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
How wrong could I be? Journal of Consciousness Studies 9: 13–16. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Hume D. (1978) A treatise of human nature. Oxford University Press, Oxford. Originally published in 1739. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Hurlburt R. T. & Heavey C. L. (2006) Exploring inner experience. John Benjamins, Amsterdam. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Hurlburt R. T. & Schwitzgebel E. (2007) Describing inner experience? Proponent meets skeptic. MIT Press, Cambridge MA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Husserl E. (2002) Zur phänomenologischen Reduktion. Husserliana XXXIV. Kluwer, Dordrecht. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Husserl E. (2004) Ideas: General introduction to pure phenomenology. Routledge, London. Originally published in 1913. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Jack A. & Roepstorff A. (2002) The “measurement problem” for experience: Damaging flaw or intriguing puzzle? Trends in Cognitive Sciences 6: 372–374. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
James W. (1890) The principles of psychology. Holt, Baltimore. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Johansson P., Hall L., Sikström, S., Tärning B. & Lind A. (2006) How something can be said about telling more than we can know: On choice blindness and introspection. Consciousness and Cognition 15: 673–692 ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Kriegel U. (2013) A hesitant defense of introspection. Philosophical Studies. In press. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Lachaux J.-P. (2011) If no control, then what? Making sense of “neural noise” in human brain mapping experiments using first-person reports. Journal of Consciousness Studies 18: 162–166 ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Levi-Strauss C. (1958) Anthropologie structurale. Plon, Paris. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Locke J. (1975) An essay concerning human understanding. Oxford University Press, Oxford. Originally published in 1690. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Lyons W. (1986) The disappearance of introspection. MIT Press, Cambridge MA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Mangan B. (2007) Cognition, fringe consciousness, and the legacy of William James. In: Velmans M. & Schneider S. (eds.) The Blackwell companion to consciousness. Blackwell, London. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Marcel A. (2003) Introspective report. Journal of Consciousness Studies 10: 167–186. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Marti S., Sackur J., Sigman M. & Dehaene S. (2010) Mapping introspection’s blind spot: Reconstruction of dual-task phenomenology using quantified introspection. Cognition 115: 303–313 ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Merickle P. M., Smilek D. & Eastwood J. D. (2001) Perception without awareness: Perspectives from cognitive psychology. Cognition 79: 115–134 ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Nisbett R. E. & Wilson T. D. (1977) Telling more than we can know: Verbal reports on mental processes. Psychological Review 84: 231–259 ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Overgaard M., Koivisto M., Sørensen T. A., Vangkilde S. & Revonsuo A. (2006) The electrophysiology of introspection. Consciousness and Cognition 15: 662–672. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Petitmengin C. & Bitbol M. (2009) The validity of first-person descriptions as authenticity and coherence. Journal of Consciousness Studies 16: 363–404. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Petitmengin C. (2001) L’expérience intuitive. L’Harmattan, Paris. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Petitmengin C. (2006) Describing one’s subjective experience in the second person: An interview method for the science of consciousness. Phenomenology and the Cognitive Science 5: 229–269. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Petitmengin C. (2011) Describing the experience of describing? The blind spot of introspection, Journal of Consciousness Studies 18(1): 44–62. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Petitmengin C., Bitbol M., Nissou J.-M., Pachoud B., Curallucci H., Cermolacce M. & Vion-Dury J. (2009) Listening from within. Journal of Consciousness Studies 16: 252–284. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Petitmengin C., Remillieux A., Cahour B., Thomas S. (2013) A gap in Nisbett and Wilson findings? A first-person access to our cognitive processes. Consciousness and Cognition 22(2): 654–669. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Piccinini G. (2003) Data from introspective reports. Journal of Consciousness Studies 10: 141–156. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Piccinini G. (2009) First-person data, publicity, and self-measurement. Philosophers Imprint 9(9): 1–16. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Pickering A. (1995) The mangle of practice. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Prinz J. (2004) The fractionation of introspection. Journal of Consciousness Studies 11: 40–57. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Rudrauf D., Lutz A., Cosmelli D., Lachaux J.-P. & Le Van Quyen M. (2003) From autopoiesis to neurophenomenology: Francisco Varela’s exploration of the biophysics of being. Biological Research 36: 21–59. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Schwitzgebel E. (2004) Introspective training apprehensively defended: Reflections on Titchener’s lab manual. Journal of Consciousness Studies 11: 58–76. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Shanon B. (1984) The case for introspection. Cognition and Brain Theory 7: 167–180. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Shanon B. (2003) The antipodes of the mind. Oxford University Press, Oxford. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Silverman M. & Mack A. (2006) Change blindness and priming: When it does and does not occur. Consciousness and Cognition 15: 409–422. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
the mythical origins of scientific psychology. Consciousness and Cognition 15: 634–654. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Thompson E. (2007) Mind in life. Harvard University Press, Cambridge. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Titchener E. B. (1912) The schema of introspection. American Journal of Psychology 23: 485–508. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Tye M. (2009) Consciousness revisited. MIT Press, Cambridge MA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Varela F. J. (1996) Neurophenomenology. Journal of Consciousness Studies 3: 330–349. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Varela F. J., Thompson E. & Rosch E. (1993) The embodied mind: Cognitive science and human experience. MIT Press, Cambridge MA. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Vermersch P. (1994) L’entretien d’explicitation. ESF, Paris. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Vermersch P. (1999) Introspection as practice. Journal of Consciousness Studies 6: 15–42. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Wilson T. D. & Dunn E. W. (2004) Self-knowledge: Its limits, value, and potential for improvement. Annual Review of Psychology 55: 493–518. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Wittgenstein L. (1958) Philosophical Investigations. Basil Blackwell, Oxford. Originally published in 1953. ▸︎ Google︎ Scholar
Comments: 0
To stay informed about comments to this publication and post comments yourself, please log in first.